The New York Mets front office spent the offseason telling fans not to panic. They said the revamped starting rotation would more than make up for the emotional gut punch of losing Pete Alonso, Brandon Nimmo, and Edwin Diaz. But eight weeks into the experiment, a troubling pattern is emerging — and it centers on the man who was supposed to be the co-ace: Freddy Peralta.
Tuesday night’s 7-0 drubbing at the hands of the St. Louis Cardinals was supposed to be a statement game. Instead, it became a flashing red light. Peralta lasted six innings but surrendered six runs on six hits, issuing two walks in the process. The Citi Field faithful watched in disbelief as the Dominican right-hander put the Mets in a 6-0 hole by the fourth inning. The lineup, lacking the star power of recent years, had no answer.
Manager Carlos Mendoza, in his third year at the helm, offered what sources close to the club describe as a carefully measured assessment. “He’s been good for the most part,” Mendoza said, according to the SNY Mets X account. “When you look at his numbers, there have been outings where it’s a grind for five innings but he gives us a chance to win a baseball game. There’s been a few of them where he’s been pretty good. And then there’s a couple of them like tonight — I think there was one in Miami, too — where, yes, he went six today, over there he went seven, but gave up a lot of runs. But for the most part, he continues to give us a chance to win baseball games.”
But behind the scenes, insiders say the mood in the clubhouse is far less diplomatic. One team source, speaking on condition of anonymity, told us: “They brought him in to be the guy. He was supposed to be lockdown. Right now, he’s a coin flip — and that’s not going to cut it in this division.”
Peralta now sits at 4-5 with a 4.04 ERA through 14 starts. Those numbers, on their own, aren’t catastrophic. But context is everything. The Mets entered Tuesday ranked in the top 10 in ERA as a staff, yet they sit 29-37 — ahead of only the San Francisco Giants and Colorado Rockies in the entire National League. That gap between staff stats and team record is reportedly causing serious internal concern.
The bigger picture is even more unsettling. Peralta is in a contract year, coming off the best season of his MLB career. The expectation — both from the front office and the fanbase — was that he would pitch like a frontline starter, not a mid-rotation roll of the dice. But according to multiple league observers, his inconsistency has become a pattern: dominant one start, hittable the next. Against the Cardinals, he was the latter, and the result was an embarrassing shutout loss.
What happens next could define the Mets’ season — and Peralta’s future. With the trade deadline approaching and the playoff picture looking bleak, sources suggest the front office is already weighing uncomfortable options. A trade of a struggling veteran on an expiring contract? A demotion to the bullpen? Those are reportedly conversations that are being had behind closed doors.
For now, Mendoza is sticking to the script. But the clock is ticking. Peralta’s next start, insiders say, will be scrutinized like a playoff game. If he wobbles again, the whispers will become shouts — and the Mets’ season may officially be over before the All-Star break.
Leave a Comment