The Buffalo Bills made a pretty loud statement this offseason without saying much at all. They traded for DJ Moore, a proven No. 1 receiver who has done it on multiple teams with inconsistent quarterback play. That move told you exactly what the front office thinks about the current state of the receiving room.
And it put Keon Coleman on notice.
Coleman is entering Year 3, which is normally when second-round picks either lock down a starting job or start hearing their name in trade rumors. Right now he’s teetering somewhere in between. Through two seasons he’s got 67 catches and 960 yards. That’s not terrible for a complementary piece. But it’s not what you want from a guy the Bills spent premium draft capital on when they expected him to grow into a primary target for Josh Allen.
The pecking order changed fast
Before the Moore trade, you could squint and see Coleman as the eventual No. 1. He’s 6-foot-4 with strong hands and the kind of body control that makes contested catches look routine. The flashes are real. The problem is they’ve been flashes — moments scattered across 33 games instead of consistent production week to week.
Now Moore is the clear top guy. Khalil Shakir has quietly become one of the most reliable slot receivers in the league. Dalton Kincaid is emerging as a matchup problem at tight end. Coleman is competing for targets against all of them, plus whoever else Buffalo rotates in. That’s a crowded room for a guy who still needs to prove he can win consistently on the outside.
What Buffalo actually needs
The Bills don’t need Coleman to lead the team in receiving. They need him to be the guy who wins when the offense absolutely needs a conversion on third-and-7. They need someone who draws enough attention that defenses can’t double Moore and Kincaid on every important snap. They need a physical presence who can go up and get a 50-50 ball when Allen scrambles and buys time.
Coleman has shown he can do that in moments. The question is whether he can do it every week.
When reporters asked him about the doubters during OTAs, he brushed it off. “I really don’t care.” That’s fine. Confidence is part of the job description for NFL receivers. But ignoring the noise and making it stop are different things.
Year 3 is a real turning point for wideouts. Some guys finally put it together and become dependable starters. Others get replaced by the next draft class and spend the rest of their careers bouncing around the league. The Bills made their choice clear: they’re going all in on Allen’s prime. They aren’t waiting on development projects anymore.
If Coleman takes the leap, Buffalo’s offense gets scary. Defenses can’t shade everything toward Moore when there’s another guy on the other side who can burn them. If he doesn’t, the Bills will find someone else. They’ve already shown they will.
So this season isn’t really about proving fans wrong or shutting up the critics. It’s about proving to the people who control his future that he belongs in the long-term plan. With a Super Bowl roster around him and a quarterback who can make anyone look good, the opportunity is right there.
Coleman just has to take it.
Leave a Comment