The Atlanta Braves are in first place despite a pitching staff that has been held together with tape and a prayer. And that’s exactly why they can’t afford to make a timid move at the deadline.
Injuries have rattled this rotation all year. Chris Sale looks like the only guy you’d trust in October right now. Hurston Waldrep just got back from the injured list. Reynaldo López moved back into the rotation to plug a hole. It’s not a situation where one middle-tier arm changes the math.
According to The Athletic’s Jesús Cano, the Braves should be selling the farm this year. His argument is blunt: no prospect is untouchable when you have a core of Matt Olson, Ozzie Albies, Ronald Acuña Jr. and Austin Riley under contract. With a potential lockout looming, the window to win another ring is now.
Small moves are a waste of time
Picking up a fringe reliever or a rental bat who doesn’t move the needle? That’s just window dressing. The Braves are 9.5 games up on the Phillies, but that lead has been shrinking as the summer wears on. The Marlins are lurking too, playing better than anyone expected. If Atlanta settles for a minor piece, they could end up fighting for a Wild Card spot instead of running away with the division.
ESPN’s Jeff Passan floated the idea of C.J. Abrams as the dream shortstop fix. The Nationals’ young star would lock down a position that’s been a revolving door since Ha-Seong Kim’s offensive struggles. But an intradivision trade for that kind of talent? Passan called it the unlikeliest of dream scenarios. Short of that, the Braves are looking at Jorge Mateo and Mauricio Dubón holding the fort, with top prospects like Tate Southisene and Alex Lodise still years away in A-ball.
The pitching gamble
Tarik Skubal is the other name that keeps coming up. A rental ace who could tilt a playoff series. But here’s the problem: can the Braves convince Skubal to stay long term? And even if they add him, can they really beat the Dodgers in a seven-game series? If the answer to either question is shaky, trading multiple top prospects for a two-month rental feels reckless.
MLB.com’s Mark Bowman pointed out that the Braves have the prospect capital and financial flexibility to go after any starter available. The real question is whether they have the stomach to move those guys. Bryce Elder is trying to turn things around. Waldrep is back. López is stretched out. None of those options inspire confidence against the top of the National League.
The Braves proved everyone wrong by racing to that huge lead after the preseason predictions had them fighting for a Wild Card at best. But the pitching injuries were brutal. Spencer Strider went down. Max Fried missed time. The depth evaporated. And now the margin for error is gone.
If Atlanta goes small, they’ll waste a year of prime Acuña and Olson. If they go big, they might overpay for a rental. Either way, the wrong move is a half-measure. The Braves need to either go all in or accept that this isn’t their year. Anything in between just kicks the problem down the road.
Leave a Comment