The Chris Sale trade looked like a hospital bill the Braves were stuck with. An aging arm, a massive contract, and a history of injuries that made the whole thing feel like a desperation move. But then something weird happened. Sale started pitching like it was 2018 again.
Mark DeRosa broke it down bluntly on MLB Central. He called the trade a risky gamble by Alex Anthopoulos, who took on the money and made it work. Boston chipped in $17 million to help grease the wheels, which is the kind of subsidy that makes a bad bet look smart in hindsight.
And the results have been borderline ridiculous. Sale is 9-6 with a 2.27 ERA and a 1.116 WHIP across 16 starts. His fastball has life again. His slider has that old bite. For a Braves rotation that has been absolutely wrecked by injuries, that consistency every five days has been worth every dollar.
The Hall of Fame question that won’t go away
DeRosa didn’t dodge it when it came up. He admitted he’s a body of work guy, which is a fancy way of saying he votes like it’s 1985. But he also said voters are starting to look at dominance within windows. That’s the tension at the heart of Sale’s case.
On paper, the resume is undeniable. Ten All-Star appearances. A 2024 NL Cy Young. Three strikeout titles. And he’s fanned over 500 batters with three different teams. That kind of company is rare enough that the Hall of Fame conversation was inevitable.
But DeRosa didn’t back down from his old-school take. “Because his body of work, for me, doesn’t say Hall of Famer,” he said, before adding that he views Hall cases through a 1970s and 1980s lens. That kind of honesty is refreshing, even if it’s frustrating for Braves fans who watch Sale carve up lineups every fifth day.
Peak vs. longevity
The whole debate comes down to one thing. Do you reward a guy who was arguably the best pitcher in baseball for a five-year stretch but couldn’t stay on the field the rest of the time? Or do you hold the door for guys who racked up counting stats by being good enough for 15 years?
Sale’s peak screams greatness. His current run with Atlanta only strengthens the case. For a fan base that watched him arrive as a question mark and turn into a Cy Young winner, the answer is obvious. But for voters like DeRosa, the math isn’t that simple.
Under the lights at Truist Park, none of that matters. Sale is giving the Braves exactly what they needed. The Hall debate can wait. The roar, right now, is enough.
Leave a Comment