Jason Robertson is back in Dallas on a one-year, $12 million deal. That sounds like a lot of money, because it is. But it also sounds like a band-aid on a situation that could get ugly fast.
The Stars and Robertson avoided arbitration by signing this contract Tuesday, which buys them time. But time for what? That’s the question hovering over this whole thing.
Robertson wanted a long-term deal. The Stars wanted a long-term deal. They couldn’t get there. So now they’ve got a one-year bridge that basically dares the other side to blink first. It’s the hockey equivalent of kicking the can down the road and hoping the road doesn’t dead-end.
Let’s be real about what this means.
The Stars Are Playing a Dangerous Game
Dallas traded for Matt Duchene’s contract and kicked the can on Tyler Seguin’s money coming off the books next summer. The cap math works eventually. But eventually isn’t the same as right now. And right now, Robertson can walk straight into unrestricted free agency in July 2025 with zero strings attached.
The Stars reportedly fielded trade offers during this standoff, including a rumored deal that would have sent Robertson to Seattle. That didn’t happen. Robertson vetoed the extension with the Kraken that would have brought draft picks and prospects back to Dallas. Good for him. Bad for the Stars.
If Robertson plays out this season and leaves for nothing, that’s not just a miss. That’s an organizational failure. You don’t let a 25-year-old who just put up 109 points in 74 games walk for nothing. So the pressure is on Dallas to get an extension done. But they can’t even talk about it until January 1. That’s a long time to let a situation simmer.
Grade for the Stars: C+. That C slides up to an A if they lock him up long-term by February. But it drops toward an F if he’s wearing another jersey next fall.
Robertson Holds All the Cards Now
Matthew Tkachuk wrote the playbook in 2022. Get one year from UFA, use it as leverage, and pick your destination. Robertson didn’t force a trade to Seattle. He stayed in Dallas, which is what he said he wanted all along. But now he’s got a year to prove he’s worth even more than $12 million.
And he probably will. Robertson is already one of the most efficient scorers in the league. A full season next to Roope Hintz and Joe Pavelski (or whoever fills that line) and he could push for 120 points. That kind of production sets him up for a contract that resets the market.
All reports say Robertson wants to stay in Dallas. But wants and business don’t always line up. If the Stars can’t get a deal done by July, Robertson can talk to every team in the league. Not just Dallas trade partners. Every single one.
Grade for Robertson: A-. He wanted term. He didn’t get it. But he got $12 million for one season and the ability to write his own ticket next summer. That’s not a bad place to be.
The real question is whether the Stars will figure it out before it’s too late. They’ve got until January 1 to start talking. They’ve got until July to get it done. After that, the price only goes up.
Leave a Comment